2026-09-02
User:
Repo: redacted (a novel). Read-only task; do not edit any file, do not run git, never read notes/sealed/.
Read draft/book-01/scenes/25-.md through 118-.md in order (94 scenes, ~100k words; use cat in batches). Then read notes/canon/world/timeline.md and notes/canon/characters/{edwin,peri,redacted}.md.
Task: a book-wide CONTINUITY read for the stretch that is about to be published. Report only concrete contradictions between scenes, or between a scene and the timeline/character files, that a careful reader would catch:
- names, ages, spellings of people and places changing
- dates, day counts, durations, distances, sums of money, counts (worms, stakes, chains, people) that disagree with an earlier statement
- who knows what when (a character acting on information they have not been given on the page, or being told the same thing twice as news)
- physical state (redacted and redacted: which arm, when set, when off; Peri's cut hand; who is carrying what)
- objects appearing/disappearing (the auger, the sword, the notebook, letters)
- weather and time of day within a scene sequence
- the order of events being referred to later in the wrong order
Do NOT report style, voice, pacing, or things you merely find implausible. Do not report anything about what the silent-soil mystery is; canon is deliberately agnostic on its cause.
Output: a numbered list, each item: scene numbers involved, the two quoted phrases that conflict (exact, short), one line on which is more likely right given the surrounding scenes and the timeline. Then a short list of "possibly deliberate, check with the author" items. Aim for precision over volume; a reader with only your list must be able to fix each item without re-reading the book.
I'll start by reading the scenes.
π§ Bash: ls draft/book-01/scenes/ | head -130 && echo "---" && wc -w draft/book-01/scenes/*.md | tβ¦
β 120 lines, 3070 chars
π§ Bash: redacted sentence: unpublished prose redacted.md 2>&1; ls notes/canon/characters/
β 14 lines, 272 chars β 891 notes/canon/world/timeline.md / 972 notes/canon/characters/edwin.md / 1338 notes/canon/characters/peri.md
π§ Bash: cd redacted/draft/book-01/scenes && for f in 2[5-9]-* 3[0-9]-* 4[0-4]-*; do echo "=====β¦
β 21 lines, 1932 chars
π§ Bash: cd redacted/draft/book-01/scenes && for f in 2[5-9]-* 3[0-4]-*; do echo "===== $f"; catβ¦
β 21 lines, 1929 chars
π§ Bash: cd redacted/draft/book-01/scenes && S=redacted: private && mkdir -p $S && python3 -c β¦
β 11 lines, 1252 chars
I'll read the batches in order.
π§ Read redacted: private
β 570 lines, 75868 chars
π§ Read redacted: private
β 524 lines, 72431 chars
π§ Read redacted: private
β 434 lines, 61959 chars
π§ Read redacted: private
β 420 lines, 65022 chars
π§ Read redacted: private
β 434 lines, 70741 chars
π§ Read redacted: private
β 430 lines, 61167 chars
π§ Read redacted: private
β 408 lines, 59425 chars
π§ Read redacted: private
β 418 lines, 65139 chars
π§ Read redacted: private
β 436 lines, 63120 chars
π§ Read redacted: private
β 192 lines, 27020 chars
π§ Bash: sed -n 1,200p notes/canon/world/timeline.md
β 200 lines, 12098 chars
π§ Bash: sed -n 200,520p notes/canon/world/timeline.md
β 321 lines, 20220 chars
π§ Bash: sed -n 520,700p notes/canon/world/timeline.md
β 181 lines, 10764 chars
π§ Bash: sed -n 1,120p notes/canon/characters/redacted.md
β 119 lines, 7089 chars
π§ Bash: grep -n -i "eighteen\|nineteen\|birthday\|age\|sword\|redacted\|notebook\|left hand\|scβ¦
β 60 lines, 5391 chars
π§ Bash: grep -n -i "left-handed\|handed\|staff\|three hundred and fifty\|350\|331\|age" notes/canβ¦
β 40 lines, 2968 chars
π§ Bash: cd redacted/draft/book-01/scenes && grep -oh "redacted\|redacted\|redacted\|Ferriβ¦
β 36 lines, 416 chars
π§ Bash: cd redacted/draft/book-01/scenes && grep -n "ewes\|three hundred ewes\|two hundred andβ¦
β 28 lines, 17700 chars
π§ Bash: cd redacted/draft/book-01/scenes && grep -n "eight days it's pushed\|out for five" 59*.β¦
β 15 lines, 9992 chars
redacted sentence: unpublished prose redacted character files. The book is unusually tight on dates β most of the arithmetic I checked (the 41/49-day Holm Deep counts, the 82-day "eleven weeks and five days", the chain figures, Day-N β date, "seventy miles in eleven days", "twenty-seven days in the parish") is exactly right. What follows is what a careful reader could catch.
59 vs 60 (same day, 10 Harvestmonth) β how long the mouth has blown.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose
60 is right. By the slate read aloud in 59 itself, the mouth drew on 28 Cornmonth, was "nothing either way" on 2 Harvestmonth, and first blew out on the 5th; 63 confirms it on the 13th ("blown out for eight days"). In 59, "eight days" should be five (eight is the gap since it stopped drawing, which the same speech already gives as twelve).
56 vs 66 β the Seal's cooldown lands two days early.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose redacted sentence: unpublished prose
66 is right and is the canon anchor (timeline: cast Day 1 = 15 Cornmonth, returns at midnight ending 13 Harvestmonth). On 7 Harvestmonth the count should read seven left, not eight; "eight left" would put the return on the 15th.
110 misdates the "least useful adult present" speech.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose unpublished redacted sentence: unpublished prose Fix 110 to "the tenth".
92 vs 39 β when Edwin last wrote to Sorrel.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose
39 is on the page and load-bearing; the 20th of Cornmonth is the date of his letter to Marsh (quoted back at him in 85). Either the interval becomes forty days from the 25th, or the sentence needs recasting ("not written her a proper letter sinceβ¦").
117 β redacted agreement figure changes inside one scene.
redacted, at the count: "Nine of eleven ... Two a yard short. That's the figure." Peri, dictating the entry a page later: "they agree to a hand at ten of twelve and to a yard at two."
Nine of eleven is right (eleven pegs, two moved a yard). "Ten of twelve" both contradicts it and mis-totals (10 + 2 = 12 β 11); it looks like the twelve stakes leaking into the pegs count.
73 vs 54 β where Peri's boots were mended.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose
redacted sentence: unpublished prose 73 should say Ranner's Sluice β and "done it badly" contradicts the luck the coincidence list is built on.
86 β the west-line projection is measured from a reading that does not exist.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose
The only west-line readings on the page are 6 ch 20 on 28 Cornmonth (43) and 6 ch 18 on the 29th (43); nothing is chained on "the fourth" of any month. redacted sentence: unpublished prose
85 vs 89/93 β Edwin's promised date to Marsh is impossible as written.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose I am at your works that day."* They leave Fenholt on the 4th (89) and it is three days' walk (Blackrow, east house, redacted on the 6th), which 93 then treats as being "two days late". Either the letter should promise a later day, or the two-days-late reckoning at the gate needs rewording β as it stands the most date-careful man in the book writes an arrival date he cannot physically make, and nobody notices.
111 β redacted misdates the second-gate conversation.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose on the thirteenth (canon: "23:52 on the 13th"). The rest of her sentence ("fifty-six days") is correct as counted from midnight of the 13th/14th.
51 vs 52 β the pale-field trip loses its travel day.
51 (30 Cornmonth): "The day after tomorrow ... Three days: a day there, a day in it, a day back, fourteen miles each way" β 52 has them at redacted's gate and hand-walking eleven twigs across the whole afternoon on the 2nd of Harvestmonth, i.e. the day they set out, fourteen miles away. The plan says three days; the prose spends two. redacted sentence: unpublished prose
43 / 44 / 49 β "the fourteenth" is two different counting systems in adjacent paragraphs.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose
The day-numbers count from Peri's arrival (Day 14 = 28 Cornmonth), which no reader can derive; and the stakes were driven on 25 Cornmonth, so "on the fourteenth, with the stakes" reads as a date that contradicts the stake date. Recommend converting all three to days of the month.
110 vs 78 β what Peri's level 7 was for.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose The arm belongs to eight, not seven.
redacted sentence: unpublished prose unpublished's title and text say four ("Posted the thirtieth", read on 4 Saltmonth). The scene is right; the canon line is stale.
timeline.md Day 82 and peri.md both record [Agent of Fate β Level 26] at Wystow on 6 Saltmonth; scene 110 unpublished says level ten (and 117 says eleven). The character file's own "Level curve, superseded" note says 26 was overruled β the Day 82 bullet was never updated.